Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy: An Effective Treatment for Children with Trauma-Attachment Disorders
Posted
Date
11/21/2005
There is an effective treatment for children with trauma-attachment
disorders, Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy. This three part article describes
a research study demonstrating the effectiveness of the Dyadic Development Psychotherapy
approach. Traditional forms of treatment such as play therapies, talk-therapies,
behavior-modification, level systems, charts, stickers, and similar treatment
methods are ineffective with such children, but Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy
is an effective treatment method.
Children with histories of maltreatment, such as physical and
psychological neglect, physical abuse, and sexual abuse, are at risk of developing
severe psychiatric problems. These children are likely to develop Reactive Attachment
Disorder. These children have trauma-attachment problems. The trauma experienced
is the result of abuse or neglect, inflicted by a primary caregiver, which disrupts
the normal development of secure attachment. This study measured the treatment
outcomes for trauma-attachment disordered children using Dyadic Developmental
Psychotherapy an attachment-based treatment approach.
Approximately 2% of the population is adopted, and between 50%
and 80% of such children have attachment disorder symptoms. Many of these children
are violent and aggressive and as adults are at risk of developing a variety
of psychological problems and personality disorders, including antisocial personality
disorder, narcissistic personality disorder, borderline personality disorder,
and psychopathic personality disorder . Neglected children are at risk of social
withdrawal, social rejection, and pervasive feelings of incompetence19. Children
who have histories of abuse and neglect are at significant risk of developing
Post Traumatic Stress Disorder as adults. Children who have been sexually abused
are at significant risk of developing anxiety disorders (2.0 times the average),
major depressive disorders (3.4 times average), alcohol abuse (2.5 times average),
drug abuse (3.8 times average), and antisocial behavior (4.3 times average).
The effective treatment of such children is a public health concern.
Trauma-attachment disordered children have internalized a negative
working model of the world, adults, relationships, and themselves. The disorganized
attachment pattern describes the etiology and psychology of children with trauma-attachment
disorders7. Significant early neglect and abuse cause important neurobiological
dysfunction , including difficulty regulating affect and an incoherent autobiographical
narrative. A child uses the parents state of mind to regulate the childs
own mental processes . The childs developing capacity to regulate emotions
and develop a coherent sense of self requires sensitive and responsive parenting.
The best predictor of a childs attachment classification is the state
of mind with respect to attachment of the birth mother5. A birth mothers
attachment classification before the birth of her child can predict with 80%
accuracy her childs attachment classification at six years of age . Finally,
recent research by Mary Dozier, Ph.D. found that the attachment classification
of a foster mother has a profound effect on the attachment classification of
the child. She found that the childs attachment classification becomes
similar to that of the foster mother after three months in placement. These
findings strongly argue for a non-genetic mechanism for the transmission of
attachment patterns across generations and for the beneficial impact of a healing
and healthy relationship.
Early interpersonal experiences have a profound impact on the
brain because the brain pathways responsible for social perception are the same
as those that integrate such functions as the creation of meaning, the regulation
of body states, the regulation of emotion, the organization of memory, and the
capacity for interpersonal communication and empathy25. Stressful experiences
that are overtly traumatizing or chronic cause chronic elevated levels of neuroendocrine
hormones25. High levels of these hormones can cause permanent damage to the
hippocampus, which is critical for memory . Based on this, we can assume that
psychological trauma can impair a persons ability to create and retain
memory and can impede trauma resolution.
These findings strongly suggest that effective treatment requires
an affectively attuned relationship. Siegel stated, As parents reflect
with their securely attached children on the mental states that create their
shared subjective experience, they are joining with them in an important co-constructive
process of understanding how the mind functions. The inherent feature of secure
attachment contingent, collaborative communication is also a fundamental
component in how interpersonal relationships facilitate internal integration
in a child . This has implications for the effective treatment of maltreated
children. For example, when in a therapeutic relationship the child is able
to reflect upon aspects of traumatic memories and experience the affect associated
with those memories without becoming dysregulated, the child develops an expanded
capacity to tolerate increasing amounts of affect. The child learns to self-regulate.
The attuned resonant relationship between child and therapist and child and
parent enables the child to make sense (a left-hemispheric function) out of
memories, autobiographical representations, and affect (right hemispheric functions).
Specifically, There are several important implications of treatment
that flow from the above description. Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy is
an approach to treating trauma-attachment disordered children that is based
on attachment theory , and the previously mentioned processes. This treatment
seeks to remediate the negative working model of such children, using experiential
methods that have several important and overlapping dimensions: modeling the
healthy attachment cycle, reducing shame, safe and nurturing physical contact
that is containing, reexperiencing the affect associated with the trauma in
order to integrate the experience and not dissociate, and the interpersonal
regulation of affect. These dimensions are enacted through the use of eye contact,
physical holding, tone of voice, cognitive restructuring, psychodramatic reenactments,
and repeated implementations of the first year (needs) and second year (shame)
attachment cycles. As a result of treatment, children can affectively internalize
their adoptive or foster parents love, structuring, and nurturing, resulting
in increased ability to tolerate affect without becoming dysregulated or dissociated,
a more coherent sense of autobiographical memory, increased trust, and increased
self-esteem. Behaviorally, such children exhibit lower levels of aggression,
delinquent behaviors, thought disorders, depression, anxiety, and withdrawn
behaviors. It is though the healthy internalization of the parent that the child
comes to trust the parent and experience a drive to please the parent. This
is the beginning of conscience and morality.
References
Gauthier L, Stollak G, Messe L, Arnoff J: Recall of childhood neglect and physical abuse as differential predictors of current psychological functioning. Child Abuse and Neglect 20: 549-559, 1996. Malinosky-Rummell R, Hansen DJ: Long term consequences of childhood physical abuse. Psychological Bulletin 114: 68-69, 1993. Lyons-Ruth K, & Jacobvitz D: Attachment disorganization: unresolved loss, relational violence and lapses in behavioral and attentional strategies. In: Handbook of Attachment. ed. Cassidy J & Shaver P. NY: Guilford Press, 1999. Greenberg, M. Attachment and Psychopathology in Childhood. In: Handbook of Attachment. ed. Cassidy J & Shaver P. NY: Guilford Press, 1999. Hughes, D: The psychological treatment of children with PTSD and attachment disorganization